Dear Mrs. Meyer,
As a novelist myself and avid reader, I was intrigued to discover your Twilight Saga for teens, and, always one to be curious where energy in our culture is flowing, I was excited to check it out.
But I was just as quickly disappointed.
First let me say that your characters are fabulous. They are alive in a very real way. This is certainly an accomplishment, and not one to be overlooked as so many books today are lacking in characters that hold our attention in any lasting way. Also, yours is a book of feelings. Feelings of desire, longing, hope, sorrow, and loneliness..... the full gamut of the most private aspects of our human experience, throbbing on every page.
But I must be honest with you, and say that I have sincere concern about your protagonist, Bella, and the example she is setting for young teenage girls about what is truly important in life.
Bella is quirky, beautiful, intelligent, insightful (very), and honest..... but the only interest she has in life is Edward. She has no talent for anything at all, not sports, music, writing, ANYTHING, other than creating a romance with a rather unavailable boy.... Oh, and becoming a vampire. But that's just so she can be with him, so I guess it's technically still about him. Even her brief dabble in photography is focused 100% on him.
And this romance quickly spirals into pure obsession --from the beginning. Day in, day out, she obsesses, and allows her obsessive thinking to guide her every action.
By book 2 in your saga, she shows no interest in college, friends, music, culture, or anything other than....... Edward. Oh, and Jacob, who, it is noted in the prose repeatedly, is merely there to distract her from the pain of losing Edward.
I am seriously CONCERNED by the message you are giving young girls about their power, about who they can grow up to be if they apply themselves to something they absolutely love, namely, a passion. A passion for art, for music, for writing, for healing, medicine, math, astronomy, teaching...... ANYTHING. Anything at all that is not just a man.
Now, I think men are great. And I've been lucky enough to fall madly in love with several brilliant men in my life, but I also know that men are not a substitute for a woman having an authentic life with interests of her own. In fact, more often than not, men would prefer that women have lives of their own so that they don't end up becoming their soul focus.
Here's my confession: You see, I was Bella. I was that quirky, uncoordinated girl who devalued who her talents and obsessed on every guy I ever loved when I was a teenager, and then into my twenties.
In fact I was so convinced during my mid-twenties that my undying love of my then boyfriend would give me all the sustainence in life I needed, that I dropped out of college to be with him, a decision I regret enormously to this day, because, guess where that obsession led me? To a break-up, of course, and competing for jobs against other women more qualified than I am.
As I understand it, all healthy relationships require balance to function. Which means both people engage in passions of their own, and maybe even mutual passions. But if one or both people hang their entire world upon the other, then both are in extreme emotional danger. I know, I have been there. Eight years of therapy and I am finally seeing the light, and finding some balance within myself so that I can bring who I am, including my passions and talents for writing, playing guitar, and practicing yoga, to a relationship.
The books you have written are an unhealthy example of womanhood. Especially since Bella is so clumsy, and Edward is always having to save her. Did you write this book in 1955? I mean, she can't even dance? Noted is that once she loses him, she throws herself into as much danger as she can find to win him back. Somehow this reminds me of my dear friend whose girlfriend recently overdosed on painkillers so that he wouldn't break up with her. And he loyally sat by her in the hospital until he could get home and throw all her stuff out. Because obsession is INSANITY, and should not be encouraged. Men hate it. And women suffer.
Your character is a girl with no talents, no interests, no hobbies, skills, or passions whatsoever aside from her love interest. I think you need to ask your conscience if this is really the message girls need today about their power.
I noticed also that Edward, her on and off boyfriend, is a both a brilliant musical composer and a talented athlete. Why did you give him all the gifts? Because as an author, it was your choice to make her helpless and clumsy, and him powerful, talented, and godly.
Here in Los Angeles where I live, we are in the era of the "pin-up princess", where women like Paris Hilton get six digit paychecks to attend parties. That's her JOB. I will leave it to you to decide if she has cultivated any talent. And young girls everywhere look up to that and aspire to be just like her. I mean, at least Lindsay Lohan can act!
If you had a daughter, what would you dream for her? Would you encourage her to cultivate her strengths and interests over any fleeting romantic interest? OF COURSE you would. You would want her to have a wonderful boyfriend AND an inner life.
I just want you to think about the example you have set for young girls. Obsession is not love. Neither is desire. Obsession is a dangerous drug that takes the place of genuine passion and interest in life, and ultimately, it doesn't win the hearts of any of the talented, intelligent, handsome men I have ever met.
I realize that the success of your books has hinged upon how well American teens relate to your characters, and I just encourage you to plant some seeds in a healthy direction, for them, for our culture, to show both the beauty AND the wisdom that women have. I mean, we are in an age where a woman just ran for president. Aren't you just a little concerned that even politics are setting a better example for young girls than your books?
That said, I genuinely think you are a talented writer, and deserve the success you have achieved. I just pray, from one woman to another, from one novelist to another, that you take responsibility for the messages in your work.
Sincerely,
Kaia Hollan Van Zandt